If you’re reviewing your PCP agreement and questioning whether your interest rate was fair, you may come across the term “base sheet” – sometimes also called a dealer rate card. Understanding what this internal document is, how it works, and how it relates to your APR can help you spot whether you may have overpaid. Following the Supreme Court ruling on 1 August 2025, most complaints are now assessed under Consumer Credit Act 1974 s.140A (“unfair relationship”). The FCA has paused firms’ final responses on commission-related complaints until 4 December 2025 while it consults on a redress scheme, with payments expected from 2026.
What Is a PCP Base Sheet or Dealer Rate Card?
A base sheet is an internal document issued by a lender (such as a car-finance provider or bank) to its network of approved dealerships. It outlines the standard APRs dealers are expected to offer customers based on factors such as term length and, sometimes, risk profile. Think of it as a “wholesale” benchmark that indicates what a commission-free offer might look like.
A typical base sheet may include:
- Standard APRs by term (e.g., 36, 48, 60 months)
- Any commission bands/uplifts the dealer could apply (pre-28 January 2021)
- Guidance on promotional rates or exceptions
Customers don’t usually see base sheets. If you want to understand how your APR was set, you can request your file (credit application, SECCI, any commission disclosures and underwriting notes) via a data subject access request (DSAR) to your lender.
Why Base Sheets Matter in PCP Mis-Selling Complaints
Historically, some dealers were allowed to increase the APR to earn more commission under Discretionary Commission Arrangements (DCAs). The FCA banned DCAs from 28 January 2021 because they created a conflict of interest and weren’t transparent. In a complaint, evidence that your APR sat well above the lender’s base rate at the time may support an argument that commission influenced pricing and that key information wasn’t properly explained.
Important: APRs can also vary for legitimate reasons (e.g., your credit/risk profile or a promotional rate ending). Differences from a base sheet are indicators, not proof by themselves.
What Counts as “Significantly Above” the Base Rate?
Base sheets often step in small increments (commonly 0.25–0.50 percentage points), so larger gaps can be a warning sign. As a rule-of-thumb only:
| Difference from Base Rate | Possible Interpretation |
| 0–1 percentage point (pp) | May reflect legitimate pricing or risk adjustment |
| 2–3 pp above base | Often excessive if not clearly explained or justified |
| 4 pp or more | Raises serious concerns and may support a complaint |
Even small uplifts compound over time and can add hundreds or thousands to the total cost.
Example: How a Base-Sheet Uplift Affects Your Repayments
| Term | Lender Base APR | Customer APR | Difference | Possible Issue |
| 48 months | 6.0% | 9.5% | +3.5 pp | Suggests a commission-linked uplift (pre-2021) |
| 36 months | 5.5% | 6.5% | +1.0 pp | Could be justified by risk or offer timing |
| 60 months | 6.25% | 10.25% | +4.0 pp | Serious concern; merits review of disclosures |
This kind of gap may indicate a hidden markup, a central issue in many pcp claims and wider car finance claims.
What the FCA Says
The FCA banned discretionary commission models on 28 January 2021 due to conflicts of interest and poor transparency. It is now consulting on historic redress for commission complaints; more detail on scope and calculation is expected after the consultation (with payments expected from 2026). During the pause to 4 December 2025, firms don’t have to issue final responses to commission complaints—but you can still submit your complaint now so it’s logged.
Signs That Your PCP APR Might Be Inflated
These questions don’t guarantee mis-selling, but they may indicate grounds to look closer:
- Was your APR 2% or more above typical/base rates at the time without a clear explanation?
- Were you unaware that the dealer could earn commission from your APR (pre-2021)?
- Did the dealership fail to explain how your APR was calculated or whether it was negotiable?
- Were affordability checks light (no payslips/bank statements recorded)?
- Were you told the APR was fixed/non-negotiable despite alternative quotes or promotions?
What to Do If You Think You Were Overcharged
You can complain directly to your lender for free, or ask a regulated service like PCP ClaimBack to assess your agreement, handle the paperwork, and advise on escalation.
- Request your file (DSAR): Ask for your SECCI, credit application, any commission disclosure/invoice, and underwriting notes.
- Compare rates: Check your contract APR against base/promotional rates that applied at the time and against any earlier quote/order form.
- Set out your complaint: Explain the gap and any missing disclosures; reference CONC 4.5 (commission transparency), CONC 5 (affordability) and CCA s.140A (unfair relationship).
- Escalate if needed: Once a final response is issued (after the FCA pause), you can refer to the Financial Ombudsman Service within its stated time limits for free.
How PCP ClaimBack helps
- Expert Claim Reviews – we identify common signs of commission-based pricing or mis-selling.
- Full Claim Management – we manage forms, deadlines and lender correspondence.
- Ombudsman Support – if your lender refuses redress, we guide you through escalation.
- You can always complain to your lender directly for free—we simply make the process easier.
PCP Claimback is a Claims Management Company. We work on a No Win, No Fee basis. A success fee between 18% and 36% (including VAT) will be charged if your claim is successful. If you cancel your claim after the 14-day cooling-off period, you may still be charged a fee to cover our reasonable costs incurred in relation to Our Services at the rate of £75 per hour (including VAT). You do not need to use our service to make your complaint, you can do this yourself for free by contacting your lender directly.