How to Identify PCP Mis-Selling by Black Horse
If you’ve purchased a car through a Personal Contract Purchase (PCP) agreement with Black Horse, part of Lloyds Banking Group, you may be unsure whether you have grounds for a Black Horse PCP claim. PCP mis-selling can be tricky to spot, and many consumers only realise potential issues once they encounter financial strain or attempt to end their agreement prematurely.
This guide is designed to help you recognise the common signs of PCP mis-selling by Black Horse, understand your options for making a claim, and safeguard your consumer rights. Following the Supreme Court ruling on 1 August 2025, most complaints are now assessed under Section 140A of the Consumer Credit Act 1974 (“unfair relationship”). The FCA has paused firms’ final responses on commission-related complaints until 4 December 2025 while it consults on an industry-wide redress scheme, with compensation expected from 2026.
1. Understanding PCP Agreements
A Personal Contract Purchase (PCP) is a popular method of financing a car purchase. With PCP, you typically:
- Pay an initial deposit.
- Make monthly payments over a fixed term (usually 2–4 years).
- Have the option to pay a final “balloon” payment (also known as the Guaranteed Future Value or GFV) if you wish to own the car at the end of the term.
PCP agreements often present lower monthly payments than other forms of finance, but they can include complex terms that some consumers might not fully understand at the time of purchase.
2. Who Is Black Horse?
Black Horse is a major UK car finance provider and part of Lloyds Banking Group. With a broad network of dealerships nationwide, they offer various finance products, including PCP plans. While many customers have had no problems with their Black Horse agreements, some have encountered potential mis-selling scenarios, such as inadequate explanations of costs or undisclosed commission.
Common Reasons for PCP Mis-Selling
- Lack of clarity regarding the total cost of the finance.
- Insufficient explanation of the final balloon payment.
- Pressure sales tactics or rushed signings.
- Failing to carry out appropriate affordability checks.
- Overemphasising the car’s predicted future value or ignoring depreciation risks.
3. Signs You May Have Been Mis-Sold
Identifying PCP mis-selling can be tricky because the deals often appear straightforward at first glance. However, certain red flags may indicate potential mis-selling:
Inadequate Explanation of Costs
If you were not informed about the balloon payment, annual mileage restrictions, or potential penalties for exceeding mileage, you may have been mis-sold.
Affordability Issues
If the monthly payments or final settlement figure stretch your finances significantly, it could mean proper affordability checks weren’t carried out.
Undisclosed Commission
Dealerships often earn commissions for selling specific finance products. Before 28 January 2021, some arrangements (discretionary commission arrangements or “DCAs”) allowed dealers to increase your APR to earn more commission, which should have been clearly explained.
Misrepresented Annual Mileage Limits
PCP agreements typically include a mileage limit that affects the car’s future value. If this was not clearly disclosed or explained, you could face large charges at the end of the term.
Pressured or Rushed Signatures
If you were rushed to sign the agreement without enough time to understand the terms, you may have grounds to challenge the agreement.
Below is a quick-reference table summarising common mis-selling signs and how they might manifest in practice:
| Mis-Selling Sign | What It Looks Like | Potential Impact |
| Inadequate Explanation of Costs | Salesperson glosses over balloon payment or total interest | You discover much higher costs when the final payment is due |
| Lack of Affordability Checks | No proof of your income or expenditure requested | Monthly payments become unmanageable, risking arrears or default |
| Undisclosed Commission | Finance deal pushes specific lenders without transparency (or pre-2021 DCA uplift) | The interest rate could be inflated to increase dealership or broker commissions |
| Misrepresented Mileage Limits | You’re not told about surcharges for extra miles | Significant penalty fees at the end of the contract |
| Pressured or Rushed Signatures | You’re asked to sign quickly, with minimal explanation | You only fully understand the agreement after you’re locked in financially |
4. Real-World Scenario
Imagine you visit a local dealership and find a car you really like. The salesperson suggests a PCP agreement with Black Horse, emphasising “low monthly payments” but barely touching on the final balloon payment. Excited to drive away, you sign on the spot.
Months later, you begin to struggle with the monthly repayments because your financial situation has changed, and you recall the balloon payment is due in 18 months. Looking more closely at the paperwork, you realise:
- You never received a clear figure for the balloon payment at the outset.
- Your estimated annual mileage (set at 6,000 miles) was unrealistic given you drive closer to 10,000 miles.
- You were unaware of potential penalty charges for exceeding mileage.
Suddenly, you’re facing unexpected costs and feeling blindsided. This is a textbook example of where mis-selling concerns can arise—underscoring why understanding your agreement from the start is crucial.
5. Gathering Evidence of Potential Mis-Selling
If you suspect your PCP agreement with Black Horse was mis-sold, gather as much evidence as possible. This will help you build a stronger case and assist any third-party adjudicator, such as the Financial Ombudsman Service or a legal adviser, in determining whether mis-selling took place.
Paperwork and Contracts
Obtain copies of your PCP contract, any addendums, and all relevant correspondence from Black Horse or the dealership.
Email Communication
If you discussed terms, final payment costs, or mileage limits via email, keep those messages organised and accessible.
Marketing Materials
Brochures or adverts that promised specific rates or features can be crucial if the final contract terms differ significantly.
Call Records or Transcripts
If you communicated by phone, check if there are recordings or transcripts you can request. These can provide evidence of what was or wasn’t explained.
By collating these items, you’ll be in a much better position to demonstrate how you believe the deal was misrepresented or insufficiently explained.
6. Steps to Take If You Suspect Mis-Selling
If you think you’ve experienced PCP mis-selling by Black Horse, the following steps can guide you:
Review Your Contract Thoroughly
Before taking any formal action, go over your PCP agreement to ensure you fully understand details such as interest rates, total payment amounts, fees, and mileage restrictions.
Contact Black Horse or the Dealership
Reach out to Black Horse or the dealership that set up the PCP. Request clarification on any terms that seem unclear or contradictory to what you were originally told.
Submit a Formal Complaint
If you remain dissatisfied with their response, you can lodge a formal complaint. This typically involves writing a letter or email outlining your concerns, demonstrating how you believe you were mis-sold, and specifying the resolution you’re seeking (e.g., compensation, reduced interest, waiver of charges, or contract cancellation). For commission-related complaints, firms are not required to issue a final response before 4 December 2025 due to the FCA pause, but submitting now logs and preserves your case for the forthcoming redress process.
Escalate to the Financial Ombudsman Service (FOS)
If you do not receive a satisfactory response once a final response is issued after the pause—or you disagree with the outcome—you can take your complaint to the Financial Ombudsman Service. The FOS will assess your case impartially to determine whether you deserve redress.
Seek Expert Advice
Consider consulting a regulated claims management company or specialist solicitor if you want professional guidance. Having an expert on your side can streamline the process and ensure you’re aware of all your options.
7. Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) About Black Horse PCP Claims
1. Can I make a claim against Black Horse if I’ve already settled my PCP agreement?
Yes. Even if you’ve paid off your agreement—or ended it early—you may still be able to pursue a claim if you believe the PCP was mis-sold or unfair. For court claims under s.140A, the general time limit is six years from when the credit relationship ends. The FCA is due to consult on an industry-wide redress scheme in October 2025, with compensation expected from 2026.
2. Will making a claim against Black Horse affect my credit score?
Simply submitting a mis-selling complaint or claim should not, by itself, harm your credit score. However, if you fall behind on your payments during the dispute, that could affect your credit report. Keep up with any agreed payments unless you’ve arranged otherwise with the lender.
3. What evidence should I gather to strengthen my Black Horse PCP claim?
Gather any documentation showing how the agreement was presented and signed:
- Your PCP agreement, including the front and back pages, plus any amendments.
- Emails, letters, or text messages that discuss the total cost, interest rates, balloon payment, or mileage limits.
- Marketing materials, brochures, or advertisements referencing specific rates or features.
- Records of phone calls or meeting notes (if available) that capture details of what you were promised.
A clear paper trail can significantly boost the credibility of your claim.
4. If Black Horse rejects my complaint, is there anything else I can do?
Yes. Once a final response is issued (after the current FCA pause), you can escalate your case to the Financial Ombudsman Service for an independent, binding decision.
5. How long does it usually take to resolve a claim against Black Horse for PCP mis-selling?
Timelines vary. The FCA has paused firms’ final responses on commission complaints until 4 December 2025. It plans to consult on a redress scheme in October 2025, with payments expected from 2026. Early indications suggest many successful claims may be around £700 per agreement (totals can add up if you financed multiple cars).
8. Ready to Make a Claim?
If you recognise any of the mis-selling signs in your Black Horse PCP agreement, don’t wait—taking action sooner rather than later can make a real difference. You can make a claim directly to the lender yourself for free.
Alternatively, you may choose to use a regulated claims management company like PCP ClaimBack to help. We specialise in helping drivers who have been mis-sold car finance contracts. Our team will:
- Review your agreement details.
- Gather and organise supporting evidence.
- Liaise with the lender and escalate complaints if needed.
- Pursue the best possible outcome on your behalf.
Submit Your Claim With PCP ClaimBack
Fill out our form to start your free, no-obligation assessment. With our expertise in PCP mis-selling, we can guide you through each stage of the claims process—helping you understand your rights and push for fair redress.
We work on a No Win, No Fee basis. If your claim is not successful, you won’t pay a penny. A success fee between 18% and 36% (including VAT) will be charged if your claim is successful. If you cancel your claim after the 14-day cooling-off period, you may still be charged a fee to cover our reasonable costs incurred in relation to Our Services at the rate of £75 per hour (including VAT).