Close Brothers Sets Aside £165m for Car Finance Compensation: What It Means for Consumers

The fallout from the car finance commission scandal continues to unfold, with Close Brothers becoming the latest lender to set aside a substantial financial provision in anticipation of potential compensation claims. The London-based bank has allocated up to £165 million to cover legal costs and possible payouts to consumers affected by mis-sold car finance agreements.

However, the bank has warned that the final compensation figure remains uncertain, as legal appeals and an ongoing Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) review could significantly alter the scope of liabilities. Analysts estimate that Close Brothers could ultimately face a much higher bill, with some suggesting it could exceed £460 million—around 35% of the lender’s total net asset value.

Understanding the Car Finance Commission Scandal

The car finance mis-selling scandal stems from a Court of Appeal ruling in October 2024, which found that it was unlawful for car dealers to receive commission payments from lenders without the informed consent of the customer. This landmark decision opened the floodgates for a new wave of complaints from consumers who suspect they were unknowingly charged inflated interest rates due to undisclosed dealer commissions.

Lenders like Close Brothers, who have been major players in the motor finance market, are now facing billions of pounds in potential compensation claims, alongside increased regulatory scrutiny from the FCA.

Despite disagreeing with the Court of Appeal ruling, Close Brothers has confirmed its intention to appeal to the Supreme Court, hoping to overturn the decision. However, unless the ruling is overturned, the legal precedent now strengthens consumer claims against lenders who failed to disclose commission payments.

How Close Brothers is Responding to the Scandal

Close Brothers’ decision to set aside £165 million is part of a broader strategy to protect its financial stability in light of mounting compensation claims. The bank has also been working to boost its capital reserves, selling its wealth management division for £200 million last September as part of its restructuring efforts.

Despite these measures, analysts warn that the ultimate cost to Close Brothers could be much higher. Moody’s, a leading ratings agency, has estimated that total redress across the motor finance sector could reach £30 billion, while some FCA officials believe it may surpass the £50 billion paid out in the PPI scandal.

For now, Close Brothers has assured investors that it remains financially stable, stating that while the provision will impact its capital strength, it will still be above regulatory requirements and capable of absorbing potential losses.

Craig Gedey, spokesperson for PCP Claimback, commented:
_“Close Brothers setting aside £165 million for potential compensation is a clear indication of the scale of this issue. While this is a step in the right direction, we know that the true cost to lenders could be significantly higher. Many consumers were unknowingly charged inflated interest rates due to hidden commission payments, and they deserve to be compensated fairly.

The Court of Appeal’s ruling has made it clear that transparency must be at the heart of car finance agreements moving forward. However, for those affected in the past, now is the time to take action. If you financed a car before 2021 and were not informed about commission payments, you may be eligible for compensation. PCP Claimback is here to support consumers through this process and ensure they get the redress they deserve.”_

What This Means for Car Finance Customers

With the FCA extending deadlines for car finance complaints and the number of claims expected to rise, now is the time for affected consumers to review their car finance agreements and check if they were charged undisclosed commission fees.

Consumer rights groups, including Consumer Voice, are urging all car finance customers who took out loans before 2021 to check whether they were impacted by hidden commissions.

Alex Neill, Co-Founder of Consumer Voice, commented:
“All car finance providers that kept customers in the dark over commission arrangements should be setting aside money to pay compensation. It is the responsibility of the dealer to ensure that car buyers both know of and agree to a commission payment.”

Many car buyers did not shop around for financing, often accepting dealer-arranged loans on the spot, making it even more crucial for consumers to have had full transparency on commission structures.

If you suspect you were overcharged on your car loan, it’s important to take action now.

How to Make a Car Finance Compensation Claim

If you financed a car, van, or motorbike before 2021 with Close Brothers, you may be eligible to make a Close Brothers PCP claim for compensation due to undisclosed commission payments.

Steps to take:

  1. Check your finance agreement – Look for any reference to commission payments or inflated interest rates.
  2. Contact your lender – Request information about whether a Discretionary Commission Arrangement (DCA) was applied to your loan.
  3. Submit a formal complaint – If you believe you were mis-sold car finance, you can file a complaint directly with your provider.
  4. Seek expert assistance – If you’re unsure how to proceed, PCP Claimback can help you navigate the claims process and ensure you get the compensation you deserve.

The Road Ahead: What Comes Next?

While Close Brothers has taken a significant step in setting aside funds, the full scale of car finance redress remains uncertain. As legal appeals move forward and the FCA continues its investigation, more lenders may follow suit, increasing the likelihood of further provisions across the industry.

The motor finance sector is facing a period of unprecedented change, and with the FCA pushing for greater transparency and fair compensation, consumers now have a stronger case than ever for reclaiming money lost to hidden fees.

If you think you’ve been affected, now is the time to act.

Related Articles